A mixed-use development slated for West De la Guerra Street in Santa Barbara would include 23 apartments and commercial space
A mixed-use development slated for West De la Guerra Street in Santa Barbara would include 23 apartments and commercial space. (DMHA Architecture rendering)

Downtown Santa Barbara is slated to get 23 new apartments.

The city’s Historic Landmarks Commission on Wednesday gave unanimous approval of a revised project design for a mixed-use development at 113 and 117 West De la Guerra St. A previous version of the project had been approved, but developer John DeWilde and the architectural firm DMHA Architecture made changes.

The site is occupied by three commercial buildings, including Elsie’s Tavern. The new project would consist of 10 two-bedroom units, 12 one-bedroom units and one studio unit. It also would consist of a commercial building fronting the project on De La Guerra.

The project has been around in some form for more than a decade. The most recent meeting was a month ago, and the developers took the HLC’s feedback seriously and returned on Wednesday with a project that the members could approve.

“The thing I like about design review, and cooperative architects and clients, is that we always end up getting a better project,” Commissioner Ed Lenvik said. “To drive around this town and realize that’s better because ABR was involved, or the Landmarks Commission was involved, makes me so happy.”

Commissioners Lenvik, Cassandra Ensberg, Keith Butler, Steve Hausz and Robert Ooley approved the project.

The new housing was proposed under the city’s average unit-sized density inventive program, which gives developers bonus density in exchange for building apartments. Santa Barbara is under pressure from the state to find locations to build up to 8,001 units by 2031. The city, much like coastal California, is also facing a housing shortage, so developers are motivated to propose projects that address the city’s jobs-housing imbalance.

The city conducted a Historic Structures Report for the current commercial buildings and determined that the building at 113 to 115 West De la Guerra was considered significant as a City Structure of Merit and regarded as a “very fine example of Spanish Colonial Revival architecture.” The building was designed in 1928 by Edwards, Plunkett & Howell. Since there were various alterations to the sides and rear, only the front façade and tile roof at 113 West De la Guerra were considered significant and will be preserved as part of the project.

A portion of the structure will have a fourth floor, which includes common open space. The project will include 23 parking spaces for the residents and three spaces for the commercial unit. A garage with a nine-foot clearance will connect the buildings.

The tallest part of the building will be about 46 feet.

Shella DuMong, one of the speakers during public comment, owns property next to the development. She has expressed concerns about security, noise concerns, privacy, light intrusion, secondhand smoke exposure, and other concerns from the rentals.

She said after meeting with the applicant that she was pleased to know that “there will be robust and responsive property management.”

“I’d like to also thank the applicant for the opportunity to have been able to meet a couple of times about some of our concerns and the way that you addressed them,” DuMong said. “And I hope that everything works out.”

Another speaker, John Campanella, a former Santa Barbara planning commissioner, owns a condo next to the project.

He, too, expressed positivity toward the developer, while also sharing concerns.

“I appreciate the fact that the common area is going to be set back from where active residents would gather,” Campanella said. “It is effectively level four, and it will look down on level-three bedrooms within our units. It would be good from the outset to design it so there’s not going to be a conflict.”

The commissioners in the end said the development was ready for approval.

“This is a great project,” Lenvik said. “It really is.”

— Noozhawk staff writer Joshua Molina can be reached at jmolina@noozhawk.com. Follow Noozhawk on Twitter: @noozhawk, @NoozhawkNews and @NoozhawkBiz. Connect with Noozhawk on Facebook.