
I frequently reflect on the competence of some Lompoc City Council members; their actions and comments provide plenty of fodder for a political commentator.
A case in point was a recent presentation by the city planning manager concerning some recommendations made by a council ad hoc committee (Councilmen Dirk Starbuck and Victor Vega) concerning changes they wanted to see in the 2030 General Plan (GP).
The General Plan is a legally binding document that reflects the community’s vision for future land uses, both public and private. It also contains all the requirements for public services such as police, fire, utilities and solid waste disposal. In other words, it is the source document and justification for everything local government does to support the community.
It is “community vision,” not the desires of specific council members or individual developers, that dictate how a community will grow and what services will be provided.
The GP contains seven required elements; others may be added if the community feels they are warranted. Required elements are land use, circulation, housing, conservation, open space, noise, and safety.
The 2030 GP started development in 2007 and it took seven years before it was finally adopted by the City Council; the primary reason was a change of political leadership in the middle of the process. The new council majority had a different set of values, thus direction to the Planning Commission was changed and more public hearings were the result.
Back in 2014, one of the current ad hoc councilmembers, Dirk Starbuck, voted to approve the current plan and certify the Environmental Impact Report. Now he wants some substantial changes to be made. On Sept. 1, the planning manager described what he termed “significant” changes to six required elements and what it would take to make those changes.
Last year the current council approved some revisions.
Included in the proposed changes were deletions of some EIR mitigation measures; those measures are the result of environmental impacts discovered as part of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) analysis that’s required during plan development.
“I am not buying a bunch of this (presentation); shalls/shoulds are not environmental,” Starbuck said. Deleting EIR mitigation measures is not an option since they were required responses to CEQA findings and were included in the certified EIR.
The planning manager explained the process; a new required element — environmental justice — must be added when two or more elements are revised. They include provision’s to:
“Identify objectives and policies to reduce the unique or compounded health risks in disadvantaged communities by means that include, but are not limited to, the reduction of pollution exposure, including the improvement of air quality, and the promotion of public facilities, food access, safe and sanitary homes, and physical activity.”
From my experience as a former planning commissioner, creating this element alone would require several months and perhaps years of public hearings before it’s ready to be sent to the council for adoption.
Other changes being proposed would also require lengthy public hearings before plan language is complete; and a new CEQA analysis and EIR would be required for the entire package, which could last a year or more after the draft document is complete.
So, as you see, changes of this magnitude to a General Plan would be a lengthy and expensive process. Public participation is essential. Considering the current COVID-19 restrictions on public meetings, trying to conduct meaningful workshops and public hearings wouldn’t be productive, and any changes adopted could later subject be subject to legal challenge.
Starbuck then said it would “take until the end of my term [two years] to allow this thing to play out, since if we can’t have the public at a council meeting, we certainly are not going to have them at a General Plan review.” He was overly optimistic.
After changes to the GP are adopted, the Zoning Ordinance would have to be revised to include the changes; particularly those created by the new Environmental Justice Element. Once again, this would take many months to years to complete.
Hearing all this, Councilman Starbuck was frustrated. “These are simple words, I just beg staff to tell us how we can do this, not why we can’t all the time,” he said. “It’s not as hard as it’s being made out to be.”
But the staff wasn’t saying “you can’t do it;” they had just told him all of the steps necessary to accomplish the ad hoc request.
Then the planning manager requested that the council establish a timeline for completion. They agreed and asked for an estimated budget; this is important since it would all come from the General Fund.
Starbuck was also concerned about the term “suggestions” saying the council “doesn’t give suggestions, it gives direction.”
Mayor Jenelle Osborne corrected him saying the “ad hoc is designed to give suggestions, and then the full recommendation and direction actually comes from the full council.” The city attorney concurred.
This leads me back to the competence of some Lompoc council members. Why after three terms as a council member didn’t Starbuck realize that government is designed to work at a snail’s pace. The General Plan is a community-generated document, and making substantial changes is a lengthy and expensive process.
— Ron Fink, a Lompoc resident since 1975, is retired from the aerospace industry. He has been following Lompoc politics since 1992, and after serving 23 years appointed to various Lompoc commissions retired from public service. The opinions expressed are his own.

