For well over 150 years a common urban planning strategy has been to “pack and stack” as many people as possible into each square foot of buildable space.

In the mid 1800s this was necessary because workers and their families needed to be close to their jobs; transportation choices were limited to trams, horses pulling carts, or walking. As the automobile, busses and commuter trains evolved, choices expanded and the suburbs were born.

In many cities like Lompoc, Santa Barbara and Santa Maria, there are scores of high-density apartment buildings that sprang up as the cities grew.

Fast forward to 2020; transportation choices are now dominated by the automobile and busses, and commuter trains have limited use in the western United States. So, you would think the need for high-density housing would diminish.

You would be wrong. Environmentalists champion high-density urban housing projects in their quest to save the earth. Public housing project designs almost always result in tightly packed groups of families.

Many people living in these projects travel either north or south of Lompoc daily to service industry jobs. This would seem to contradict the goal of environmental activists who want to reduce the carbon footprint.

While it may be “smart planning” from the perspective of land utilization and a developer’s desire to earn the greatest income from every square foot of his/her property, I have always felt that it created many problems that don’t appear obvious to either the planning authorities, developers or the public in general.

First, packing large numbers of people into proximity to one another creates friction. When your neighbor plays his entertainment center too loudly, fires up his hibachi for a couple of hours to smoke some meat, or has a cigar party, it can be irritating to the neighbors.

Last year the city of Lompoc cited numerous problems including 73 code-enforcement issues in just one 124-unit complex; there have been numerous gang-related incidents including assaults, drug dealing and murders in this same complex in the last decade.

Second, in recent weeks a contagious disease has caused governments to impose severe restrictions on gatherings of people. Their goal was to reduce exposure to the virus.  The largest numbers of illnesses and deaths have occurred in tightly packed urban centers such as in Seattle, Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York.

Last, the number of people that can occupy any public assembly area is controlled by fire safety, not public health regulations. Thus, in a restaurant with table seating, one person can be seated in every 15 square feet, and areas with concentrated use of chairs, such as a bar with a dance floor or a theater, only seven square feet of floor space per person is required.

So, did long standing urban planning policies contribute to the spread of this disease?

Most governments, including those on the Central Coast are champions of and have specific planning policies in place to create the conditions they are now banning, the packing of large numbers of people into tight spaces.

Consider this, “social distancing” is difficult in apartment buildings where tenants use common areas such as hallways, laundry rooms, trash enclosures and open-space areas. In public housing projects, it’s even more pronounced.

In extended-care facilities, patients mingle to socialize during their waking hours and at mealtime; now they are locked away in their rooms like prisoners to avoid spreading any disease.

When the current situation has been brought under control to the government’s satisfaction, it might be prudent to examine the polices that demand increased density in view of the many communicable diseases that exist in our society.

As we have learned, these diseases spread quickly; the annual cold and flu season is an excellent example of diseases that spread quickly and cause thousands of deaths annually.

The movers and shakers of government should consider the causes of disease spread as it relates to urban planning policies and building design; is there a better way?

— Ron Fink, a Lompoc resident since 1975, is retired from the aerospace industry and has been active with Lompoc municipal government commissions and committees since 1992, including 12 years on the Lompoc Planning Commission. He is also a voting member of the Santa Barbara County Taxpayers Association. Contact him at news@noozhawk.com. Click here to read his previous columns. The opinions expressed are his own.

Ron Fink, a Lompoc resident since 1975, is retired from the aerospace industry. He has been following Lompoc politics since 1992, and after serving for 23 years appointed to various community commissions, retired from public service. The opinions expressed are his own.